Subject: Policy-Discussion
List archive
- From: Mario Lipinski <mario AT cacert.org>
- To: cacert-policy AT lists.cacert.org
- Subject: Re: proposal to stop issuing class3 certificates
- Date: Sun, 17 Jan 2010 07:17:50 +0100
- Authentication-results: lists.cacert.org; dkim=pass (1024-bit key) header.i= AT cacert.org; dkim-asp=none
- Organization: CAcert (Organisation Assurance Germany, Wiki/Issue admin)
Naye from me. I do not have the feeling that this solves anything right now.
First of all I'd like to have a clean summary where the problem resides
and what has to be considered for completely fixing it and how certain
points could be addressed as well. For now this seems just hacking a
little around trying to satisfy some minor individual needs and even not
even getting further.
Deploying a completely new root seems to add too much confusion and
inconveniences for our users. So unless it proves to be audit proof and
so can be rolled out with browsers we should delay this step.
I have the feelings that our current roots are not very good and maybe
just hacking up a new Class 3 root with the current root and signing it
with SHA-1 could solve this issue. This could just be done by the
critical team ad-hoc without a decent ceremony.
--
Mit freundlichen Grüßen / Best regards
Mario Lipinski
Organisation Assurer (Germany), E-Mail:
mario AT cacert.org
Wiki/Issue admin Internet: http://www.cacert.org
CAcert.org
Support CAcert: http://www.cacert.org/index.php?id=13
http://wiki.cacert.org/wiki/HelpingCAcert
Attachment:
smime.p7s
Description: S/MIME Cryptographic Signature
- Re: proposal to stop issuing class3 certificates, (continued)
- Re: proposal to stop issuing class3 certificates, Lambert Hofstra, 01/13/2010
- Re: proposal to stop issuing class3 certificates, Philipp Guehring, 01/13/2010
- Re: proposal to stop issuing class3 certificates, Alexander Prinsier, 01/13/2010
- Re: proposal to stop issuing class3 certificates, Ian G, 01/13/2010
- Re: proposal to stop issuing class3 certificates, Philipp Guehring, 01/13/2010
- Re: proposal to stop issuing class3 certificates, Ian G, 01/14/2010
- why this is a policy vote. impact for current class3 users. why not newroots. was Re: proposal to stop issuing class3 certificates, Daniel Black, 01/15/2010
- Re: why this is a policy vote. impact for current class3 users. why not newroots. was Re: proposal to stop issuing class3 certificates, Ian G, 01/15/2010
- Re: why this is a policy vote. impact for current class3 users. why not newroots. was Re: proposal to stop issuing class3 certificates, Faramir, 01/15/2010
- why this is a policy vote. impact for current class3 users. why not newroots. was Re: proposal to stop issuing class3 certificates, Daniel Black, 01/15/2010
- Re: proposal to stop issuing class3 certificates, Faramir, 01/15/2010
- Re: proposal to stop issuing class3 certificates, Bernhard Fröhlich, 01/15/2010
- Re: proposal to stop issuing class3 certificates, Mario Lipinski, 01/17/2010
- Re: proposal to stop issuing class3 certificates, Ian G, 01/17/2010
- Re: proposal to stop issuing class3 certificates, Philipp Guehring, 01/17/2010
- Re: proposal to stop issuing class3 certificates, Lambert Hofstra, 01/17/2010
- Re: proposal to stop issuing class3 certificates, Morten Gulbrandsen, 01/17/2010
- Re: proposal to stop issuing class3 certificates, Tomáš Trnka, 01/17/2010
- Re: proposal to stop issuing class3 certificates, Morten Gulbrandsen, 01/17/2010
- Re: proposal to stop issuing class3 certificates, Ian G, 01/18/2010
- Re: proposal to stop issuing class3 certificates, Morten Gulbrandsen, 01/18/2010
- Re: proposal to stop issuing class3 certificates, Ian G, 01/18/2010
- Re: proposal to stop issuing class3 certificates, Morten Gulbrandsen, 01/17/2010
- Re: proposal to stop issuing class3 certificates, Faramir, 01/18/2010
- Re: proposal to stop issuing class3 certificates (CLOSED), Ian G, 01/18/2010
- Re: proposal to stop issuing class3 certificates, Philipp Guehring, 01/17/2010
- Re: proposal to stop issuing class3 certificates, Ian G, 01/17/2010
- Re: proposal to stop issuing class3 certificates, Lambert Hofstra, 01/13/2010
Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.16.